50 ideas to fix Michigan

Eliminate redundant state programs

The Detroit News is highlighting ideas from various groups to promote discussion on reform, restructuring government and the economy.

Eliminate redundant state programs

Idea 13: Eliminate optional services that exceed federal standards and state programs that duplicate federal programs, and do not adopt new programs unless other programs are eliminated or revenues grow.

Why: Michigan cannot support the same level of state spending it once did. Michigan programs that exceed federal standards and/or duplicate federal programs -- such as Michigan Occupational Safety and Health Administration (which is redundant considering the existence of the federal OSHA), optional Medicaid services and the wetlands program -- should be eliminated because they could be handled by the federal government.

Benefit: If Michigan did not operate its own programs that are redundant with federal programs, the state could save tens of millions of dollars. It would also help streamline permitting and regulatory processes for Michigan businesses.

How: The Legislature could eliminate programs by passing legislation or excising the programs during the budget process.

Obstacle: State bureaucrats, unions and environmental interest groups, among others. Opponents argue that federal standards often do not go far enough and Michigan should have stricter policies. Opponents also fear giving up too much of control over these policies and programs.

Source: Business Leaders for Michigan