Error processing SSI file
Error processing SSI file
Error processing SSI file
Error processing SSI file


Too tough?

What's your feeling about Toughman contests?

They should be banned
They should be more closely regulated
Don't change a thing, let 'em fight

Get results and comments

Latest Toughman news

State orders halt to Cheboygan County Toughman event
Toughman death ruled accident
Some Toughman events will be held in at least six states
Toughman bouts stopped
Female fighter severely injured

 Deaths 

DEREK CLEMENTS, 30

When: Feb. 24, 2002
Where: Grand Rapids
(World Kick-Boxing Championship)

What happened: After only four pro bouts, Clements was matched above his weight class against a former world champion and lost by a TKO after being knocked down three times. He fell into a coma and died three days later.

ERIC CROW, 23

When: Dec. 13, 1995
Where: Kansas City, Kan.

What happened: The pipe-fitter’s apprentice died after being kept alive on a respirator. Crow, who had never boxed before, entered hoping to win money for Christmas gifts. He won his first match Dec. 8 and was cleared by a chiropractor, who was acting as ringside doctor, to fight the next day. He lost that bout against a man who had fought in several previous Toughman contests, and within minutes began showing signs of brain damage. Surgeons removed a blood clot, but he slipped into a coma and never recovered.

DOUGLAS DEDGE, 31

When: March 16, 1998
Where: Kiev, Ukraine (“Boi Bez Pravil” — Battle Without Rules)

What happened: Dedge, a father of five who operated a martial-arts academy, was matched against a local wrestler, and within a minute, was face-down on the canvas. His opponent trampled him and punched him in the nape of the neck 14 times. He died two days later of severe brain damage.

BOBBY TROY DePUE, 26

When: June 11, 1994
Where: Lafayette, La.

What happened: DePue left the ring after having breathing problems. He died several hours after the bout. An autopsy revealed he died of heart disease.

ZINIOUS HAYNES, 38

When: April 9, 1995
Where: Fayetteville, N.C.

What happened: The rural carpenter fought in a Toughman bout on a Saturday night, and at 5 a.m. Sunday, awoke his mother to tell her his head hurt. An ambulance rushed him to a hospital, where he died three three hours later from a blood clot.

MICHAEL KUHN, 26

When: Sept. 20, 2002
Where: College Station, Texas

What happened: A father of two, Kuhn died after blood vessels that connected his brain and skull were severed during a Toughman bout five days earlier.

ART LIGGINS, 44

When: Sept. 15, 2002
Where: Meridian, Idaho

What happened: After an 18-year layoff from competitive boxing, Liggins, a father of five who once fought in the Olympic trials, attempted a comeback in a Toughman bout. He was knocked out in the first round and suffered fatal head injuries.

KENNY MEYLAN, 41

When: Jan. 31, 1981
Where: Lansing

What happened: A farmer from Saginaw with six children, Meylan fought once Friday and three times Saturday before he said he was “awfully tired” and collapsed. He suffered brain damage that left him a paraplegic. He died in 1998.

RON MILLER, 23

When: March 22, 1981
Where: Johnstown, Pa.

What happened: Unemployed and desperate for the $500 prize money, the 5-foot-7 former Marine fought in three Toughman bouts in two nights, even though he was dizzy and seeing double since the first match. Knocked down several times in his final bout, he was rushed to a hospital and died the next morning of brain trauma.

ROBERT ROLLINS, 33

When: July 11, 1987
Where: Montgomery, Ala.
(Bad Man Contest)

What happened: A state capitol police officer fighting in his first full-contact contest, suffered a fatal heart attack after winning. He had been taking medication for high blood pressure for several months. Rollins, who stood over 6 feet tall and weighed about 280 pounds, said after the fight that he was dizzy and unable to see.

RICKY SANDERS, 27

When: March 1992

Where: Scottsboro, Ala. (Bad Man Contest)

What happened: Knocked down several times, Sanders died a few days later of cranial cerebral trauma, according to a coroner.

SCOTT WOOD, 31

When: Jan. 24, 2003
Where: Soaring Eagle Casino, Mt. Pleasant

What happened: Wood, a former Marine who had competed in other Toughman bouts, complained he was not feeling well about 10 minutes after the Jan. 4 fight. A doctor sent Wood to a hospital in Saginaw, where he died. The medical examiner listed homicide as the cause of death.

Special Reports Archive


  Read more special reports by
The Detroit News

© Copyright 2003 The Detroit News. Error processing SSI file

Thursday, May 22

Toughman must insure fighters
LANSING -- Toughman competitions, the wildly popular organized brawls that are four times deadlier than sanctioned amateur boxing, will have to fully insure every fighter or stop doing business in Michigan.
 05/22/03

Toughman ruling is 'blessing'
LANSING -- Toughman founder Art Dore lost his fight in court, giving the competitors who enter his popular, yet brutal events the victory.
 05/22/03

Sunday, May 18

Image
Steve Perez / The Detroit News

Johnny Rodriguez, knocked out in the first round of the Toughman contest, gets medical attention from Dr. Robert Jones at the Lucky Eagle Casino in Rochester, Wash. Critics say contenders of all ages, sizes and physical conditions can sign up without having the skills or training to box.


Fighters left defenseless in Toughman rings
BOISE, Idaho -- Toughman competitions, the wildly popular organized brawls in which untrained fighters flail and pummel each other, have made the founder of the contests a millionaire while leaving some participants disfigured, brain damaged or dead.
 05/18/03

Accounts of deaths, serious injuries
 05/18/03

'Barbaric' fight ends siblings' dreams
FLINT -- When John Wayne Gibbs sang the Lord's Prayer in his tenor voice one recent Sunday morning, the congregation of Greater Friendship Azusa Church of God in Christ broke into warm smiles, then rose to applaud.
 05/18/03

Ohio, California legalize bouts to protect safety of fighters
FLINT -- Officials in California and Ohio have adopted a strategy for making Toughman fighting safer.
 05/18/03

States try but fail to ban competition
ROCHESTER, Wash. -- Idaho, Washington and Florida have tried to ban Toughman-style fights.
 05/18/03

Toughman ring doctors often lack experience
ROCHESTER, Wash. -- Ringside doctors at Toughman bouts are powerless to stop fights, forced to split their attention between ringside and backstage while fights are in progress, and, in some cases, lack proper training.
 05/18/03

Prosecutor, coroner disagree on death
Mount Pleasant -- To the Saginaw County coroner, Scott Wood was killed before hundreds of eyewitnesses at the Soaring Eagle Casino in Mount Pleasant in January.
 05/18/03

Fighters take risk for cheers, notoriety
WORLEY, Idaho -- Kelli Hochmuht, an 18-year-old horticulture major at the University of Idaho, came alive with excitement as she tried to explain what prompted her to enter a Toughman contest.
 05/18/03

Referees' calls can mean life or death
WORLEY, Idaho -- When it comes to protecting fighters, the first line of defense is the man nearest the action -- the referee.
 05/18/03

Error processing SSI file